How the calculation works

All figures are per month.

  • Lines = lines or seats you pay for × price per line.
  • Usage = metered minutes × rate per minute.
  • Service = lines + add-ons + usage.
  • Taxes and fees = service × your taxes-and-fees percentage. They apply to recurring service charges only, not to phones you bought.
  • One-time fees = setup, porting and installation ÷ contract months.
  • Phones = devices × price per device ÷ the months you spread them over.
  • Total = service + taxes and fees + one-time fees + phones; × 12 for a year.
  • Cost per user = total ÷ users. Cost per line = total ÷ lines.
  • Above the seat price = cost per user ÷ price per line − 1.

The published list prices are the US prices on each vendor’s pricing page for plans with domestic calling, billed annually and monthly, dated below. The result compares your price per line with the range of annual prices for the plans published at your size: a plan limited to 10 users, Zoom’s plan for 1 to 99 licenses, or a price band for up to 99 lines drops out when you have more. Google Voice is billed monthly only, so it counts in the monthly range and not the annual one; Microsoft publishes only a yearly price for its calling plan. 8x8 prices by quote, so it isn’t in the table. The comparison doesn’t adjust for what each plan includes, and some plans need another license (a Microsoft Teams or Google Workspace plan).

Assumptions: one month at today’s prices, with no escalators. Usage is an average month. Taxes and fees are one percentage of service charges, as entered; in practice some are per line and some are percentages.

Worked example

A company with 85 users pays for 100 lines at $22 a line (the extra 15 are conference rooms, a lobby phone and two fax lines). It pays $180 a month for add-ons, about 2,000 international minutes at $0.03, and taxes and fees come to 18% of service charges on the last invoice. Setup and porting cost $2,500 on a 36-month contract, and it bought 40 desk phones at $180, used for 36 months.

  • Lines: 100 × $22 = $2,200.
  • Service: $2,200 + $180 + 2,000 × $0.03 = $2,440.
  • Taxes and fees: $2,440 × 18% = $439.20.
  • One-time fees: $2,500 ÷ 36 = $69.44.
  • Phones: 40 × $180 ÷ 36 = $200.
  • Total: $3,148.64 a month, $37,784 a year.
  • Per user: $3,148.64 ÷ 85 = $37.04, 68.4% above the $22 seat price. Per line it is $31.49.
  • List prices: nine of the plans in the table publish a price for 85 users and 100 lines, eight of them for annual billing; $22 is within their $15 to $25 range of annual list prices, but the true cost per user is well above it, mostly from taxes and fees, phones and the 15 lines nobody uses as a person.

Where to look for savings

Start with the lines beyond users: unused licenses and analog lines for fax or alarms are common, and a POTS replacement can retire some. Then check add-ons nobody uses, the price escalator in the contract (the price escalator calculator shows what it costs over the term) and the renewal notice date in the contract renewal calculator.